House approves torture


The House today passed legislation that legalizes torture and prevents detainees from challenging their imprisonment in federal courts, voting primarily along party lines. The Senate bill is expected to pass tomorrow, sending the legislation to the President to sign before the Hill is vacated so politicians can campaign for the November election. John Boehner had something particularly vile to say prior to voting.

”Will my Democrat friends work with Republicans to give the president the tools he needs to continue to stop terrorist attacks before they happen, or will they vote to force him to fight the terrorists with one arm tied behind his back?” he asked just before members cast their ballots.

Especially upsetting was the fact that an amendment that called for an expedited judicial review of the constitutionality of the commissions and a three year sunset provision was soundly defeated, also along party lines.

You can check your Congressman’s vote here.

UPDATE: As BSB points out, Sherrod Brown chose to vote for this legislation. It’s very disappointing he did so, but as pointed out in the comments, this might have been a purely political move. The bill was in no danger of not passing, so this might put him in a position to win a few swing voters, as there is no way in hell that DeWine doesn’t approve the Senate version tomorrow. Sometimes I hate politics.

Information and Links

Join the fray by commenting, tracking what others have to say, or linking to it from your blog.


Other Posts
Boehner: Iraq has WMD, 9/11 ties
Zack Space on an interesting fundraising trip

Say Something!

Because we value your thoughtful opinions, you are encouraged to add a comment to this post. Don't be offended if your comment is edited for clarity or to keep out questionable material. Comments may even be deleted at the discretion of the Plundercrew. You signal your agreement to this by clicking 'Submit Comment' below. Everyone who comments here is responsible for them.

Plunderchat:

[…] My previous headline about this was “House approves torture“, but in reality it’s much more sinister than that. Glenn Greenwald points out that no longer is Bush simply assuming the legal authority to throw anyone - including US citizens who have never left the country - in a secret jail without the right to challenge in court, he now actually has that authority (or will, when the bill passes the Senate as expected). This last point means that even if there were a habeas corpus right inserted back into the legislation (which is unlikely at this point anyway), it wouldn’t matter much, if at all, because the law would authorize your detention simply based on the DoD’s decree that you are an enemy combatant, regardless of whether it was accurate or not. This is basically the legalization of the Jose Padilla treatment — empowering the President to throw people into black holes with little or no recourse, based solely on his say-so. […]